If you are in the journaling and productivity spaces you probably have already heard about commonplacing, journal ecosystems, and digital gardens. At first, I find it refreshing how activities that has nothing to do with your phones is becoming cool again. But that is not actually true was it?

Recently, I just started noticing how people kept on changing names for things that has already existed just to make it sound like a new discovery. The first for me was the analog bag. What the fuck is an analog bag?

Well, according to TikTokers it is a bag from which you can put all your analog stuff in it such as books, journaling supplies, coloring books, colored pencils, pens, sudoku, crossword puzzles… the list goes on.

But they must specifically be in a tote bag of course. A Traders Joe one to be exact.

They did not actually said that (but it is implied) because everyone is posting the same thing over and over again. And oh, also, everything is brand new because you know… We are all starting to cut back our screen times and live a more intentional life so we need to start somewhere... I am sure these are all still gonna be used up after 3 months right? Right?

Engk! Wrong! Because it has a different name now. And it is called brain stacking. You know, the same thing but without the fucking Traders Joe tote bag.

Look, I am not shaming these influencers. They might really just have great intentions and not just following a trendy thing. I don't know any of these people so I cannot exactly judge.

I also disagree with those that kept on complaining that everything is performative now. I used to be in the camp of, if you wanna do it, go do it.

But, seeing a good intention turn into another consumerism monster does not feel great. Especially when it affects the price and quality of some of these things that are trendy today and will be thrown away by most people tomorrow. Look at what happened to Labubus.

How did I even get here?

'Tis the season of journaling about your journaling practice for next year. I know. It's like making content about how to make content, but I digress.

Anyway so, I am constantly on YouTube watching people gush about their notebooks just to see what everyone is up to. I love listening to people that are very passionate with their interests. However, the algorithm is doing its job too well. And I am starting to get flooded by the same thing over and over again.

And now, I don't know if the problem is the algorithm or the people. They are not digital gardening anymore or doing their personal curriculum. No sir no. There is a new thing.

It's brain stacking now because calling it a hobby is not cool anymore.

Oh but, this one's new you see. Because brain stack has books to read, coloring books to color, and sudoku puzzles to solve… And of course, of course, it's all brand new because you know, they want to lessen their screen times and you need to start somewhere… Yeah.

Years ago, I already decided that watching too many journaling content is not going to make me feel like I found a community that are all just individually doing their own thing.

I watched YouTube content creators switch brands one after the other. Like some kind of sick and twisted follow the leader all in the guise of finding the right system. Which is crazy because I listen to some of these people's reasoning and most of them hate the new system. But they saw it from another person so maybe it's okay for them now since it works well for the others?

When one content creator stopped using their Hobonichi and they wanted to try a ring system, everybody else bought a Plottr. And then they said that they wanted to try the Travelers Notebook system so the rest also bought brand new leather journals that are hundreds of dollars. Everything is all about buy, buy, buy.

That first creator actually found their preferred system and still using them years later. Meanwhile, the people who followed them just all went back to what they are originally using and abandoned thousands of dollars of stationery because, just like what they thought and already knew, it did not work.

Of course it's not gonna work, you already said it in the first place. You only got these new shiny things because everybody is getting it.

Let me get it off my chest

Trends used to last for years, even decades, but now it only lasts months sometimes weeks. Even commonplace notebooks are not trendy anymore and people are switching to their digital gardens and personal textbooks. They are all the same by the way. Am I the only one getting crazy?

I feel like an old granny scoffing about junk journals because they used to call it collage or scrapbooks. Which is again, the same fucking thing.

It's the same. It had existed years ago. It will exist years from now. We don't need to rename every single thing just to get on with the times. There even is no actual significance to rename them aside from it to sound unique for the algorithm. They are just modified to reflect the time period we are in of course, but it is still. The. Exact. Same. Thing. Don't even talk to me about the aesthetics or else I am going to scream.

I get it when generations rename stuff. But when it is the same people who is desperate to make fetch happen again after only 6 months? It feels useless. It feels pointless. Who are you really doing this all for?

Yeah, brain stack really got me crashing out because it sneaked into my algorithm while I was searching for people who got their new Hobonichi planners. I just wanna see if my fountain pen inks are not gonna bleed on its papers again.

This is my "old man yells at cloud" moment. I know.

At the end of the day, people are gonna cope how they are gonna cope. This is my way of coping. I'm sure I'm not going to think about this things again after I press post... Unless there's another new thing coming. Ugh.

Oh, but it's not that deep.

Sure. Everything is not that deep to someone who lets the machine think and speak for them. Do you even know who you are?

Leave me alone.